The comparison between BIM and traditional methods has been discussed before, but the information has often been fragmented. Today, the editor of the BIM Building Training Network will provide a comprehensive summary for your reference.
Parameterized Building Model
In a digital building model, the entire structure and all design files are stored within an integrated database where every element is parameterized and interconnected. Parameter modeling is crucial to BIM because it generates coordinated, internally consistent, and computable building information, which is the core feature of BIM. Although a CAD solution might produce flat representations that look similar to outputs from parametric building modeling tools, the underlying essence is quite different.
Unlike other modeling tools, parametric building modeling tools easily coordinate all graphical and non-graphical data — including all views, drawings, tables, and more — since these are all different views of the same database. For example, if a window is positioned 1 meter away from a door within a wall, the model preserves this relationship. If the door or wall moves, the window automatically adjusts its position accordingly across all views and drawings, and all related dimensions update as well. This inherent bidirectional, real-time parameter modeling and comprehensive change propagation create high-quality, coordinated, and reliable models, making data-driven design, analysis, and documentation processes much more efficient.
Unified vs. Fragmented Architectural Processes
The construction industry traditionally operates like a siloed structure with fixed organizational boundaries. Construction projects are usually completed by several independent teams — including design, production, construction, and operations — which limits interaction between different components. Historically, digital efforts in construction were scattered and fragmented, focusing on isolated tasks such as generating drawings, renderings, cost estimates, or building management records.
BIM solutions overcome this fragmentation by replacing task-based software and connecting various building levels through unified digital modeling technology. Its parametric design approach represents a groundbreaking new computer-aided design method. Although transitioning from CAD-based technology to BIM can be challenging for some, the impact on the industry’s development is profound.
Interactive Operation
Currently, many design tools and software applications assist designers in processing design data, but a comprehensive data protocol standard guiding the industry is still lacking. Successful BIM adoption requires sharing valuable design information between these applications and enabling all project participants to access computable building data.
For instance, if architects want to test a building’s energy efficiency using building information models and adjust designs accordingly, the energy analysis software must be able to access those models. In this context, the XML standard has proven to be an effective tool for enabling interoperability. XML structures data by describing content and defining text meaning standards, facilitating data exchange between computer applications and supporting network-wide interoperability.
Staffing
Traditionally, project staffing was based on completing the extensive task of producing all construction drawings. Team roles often aligned with drawing types — plans, elevations, sections, or detailed drawings — or corresponded to building components such as core tubes, exterior walls, or halls. However, BIM solutions greatly reduce the workload associated with document preparation, making traditional project structures obsolete. Instead, BIM teams organize their work around activities such as project management, content creation, architectural design, and documentation.
Moreover, BIM represents a new approach to architectural design, not just the application of new technology. As a result, BIM teams must break away from traditional design organizations to reflect the fundamental process changes BIM brings. Many companies now use this shift to select the best designers and architects — rather than the best CAD draftsmen — to form collaborative BIM teams.
Must log in before commenting!
Sign Up